In this section of our newsletter, we have Hal answer
a direct question asked by one of our ScreamFree
Parents. Today's entry comes from our ScreamFree Parenting Forum
and it concerns the practical
application of the ScreamFree approach.
Hi, I have just finished reading ScreamFree
Parenting.
I think the book is great and the logic is wonderful. I
try not to scream, yell, threaten and scare my
children but there comes a time when too much is
too much. I am a bit confused about the exact route
we are to take. Should I let my son face the
consequence of failing?
I read the last success story in the book where
the toddler will not clean up before bed so the father
instills time outs for her and then for her books. He
remains calm and she remains upset until she finally
decides to say she misses mommy and then they talk
and she ultimately cleans up. What happens if she
didn't change her attitude. What happens if she kept
standing there screaming and not cleaning until all
the movies were in time out? That's what I need to
know.
I am not a non believer or skeptic. I just want to
make sure i am following this correctly because
obviously I want to change how things are going
here.
Believe it or not, I struggle with those same practical
questions just about every day. I'm not saying that
to sound like I can relate; I really do find myself
confused sometimes about the "business" decisions I
have to
make with my kids every day.
By "business" I am referring to those decisions
involving scheduling, structure, discipline, chores.
You know, all the unpleasant stuff that neither my
kids nor I want to deal with. But that's part of our
job as parents.
And there are no easy answers. There are no
plug-n-play techniques anyone can give that will
magically
tell you or me how to handle a son who keeps
saying "I'm coming!" while the rest of us wait in the
car. Or what to do when a daughter lies about
doing her homework.
All I can do in those circumstances is make sure I
stay calm, and focus myself on one question: "What
do I want to do here?" Not "What do I have
to do to
get my son to do...(fill in the blank)?"
It is not our job to get our kids to do anything, even
if try to do so calmly. Any efforts to get our kids to
do
something are inherently manipulative, and as such
will invite out of our kids the very defensiveness
we're trying to defeat.
I just try to remember that I cannot ever control my
kids' responses; I can only control mine. So how do I
want to respond when my kid tries to hold the
family
hostage by stalling when we have to leave? I don't
really know. Sometimes I want to calmly let him know
that we're waiting, and every minute we have to
wait is an hour he has to spend in his room later.
Sometimes I want to just sit in the car and measure
my own steam and see how long I can remain calm
(this is like lifting ScreamFree weights) and then,
when he finally comes down, inform him how much it
hurts me when he is so thoughtless of others.
Sometimes I want to go to him and work with him to
improve his time management, offering a gentle hand
to guide through territory that is still very difficult for
me, even as a grownup.
Sometimes I just want to drop-kick him into the car.
The point is that any of these responses (except the
dropkicking) can be
effective in building relationship even if none of them
are effective in changing his behavior. And
thankfully, that's what ScreamFree Parenting is all
about. This is about parenting for the long haul, not
engagning in the brief battles that can be so
distracting.
And it really sounds like you're doing great because
you're
asking great questions. Just keep asking.
And remember to take care,
Hal
Do you have a Parenting question for Hal,
the author
and creator of ScreamFree Parenting? Email Us
Directly. We will
answer a limited number of questions in upcoming
newsletters.